Johnny's Pizzeria

Discover Johnny's Pizzeria in Brooklyn, NY, renowned for the best pizzas like Grandma Pie and Garlic Knots. Enjoy authentic Italian flavors, hearty calzones, and more at 5806 5th Ave. Call +1 718-492-9735!

Welcome to Johnny's Pizzeria

Taste the Difference.

Johnny's Pizzeria
Johnny's Pizzeria
Johnny's Pizzeria
Johnny's Pizzeria

Johnny's Pizzeria offers a slice of Italy right in the heart of Brooklyn. Nestled at 5806 5th Ave, this beloved pizza spot serves up both classic and innovative dishes that keep locals coming back. Known for its delicious grandma pies and mouth-watering garlic knots, Johnny's creates a warm and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for families and friends. Here, the taste of traditional Italian cuisine meets a modern twist, ensuring a delightful experience for every patron. Whether dining in or grabbing a quick slice, Johnny's Pizzeria brings satisfaction to each visit.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

5806 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220, United States

Phone

+1 718-492-9735

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Johnny's Pizzeria
Johnny's Pizzeria
Johnny's Pizzeria
Johnny's Pizzeria

Johnny's Pizzeria stands as a cornerstone in Brooklyn's vibrant food scene. Established with the mission to deliver authentic Italian flavors, it has created a loyal following among locals and visitors alike. The pizzeria prides itself on using fresh ingredients, ensuring that each bite is packed with flavor. The signature dishes, such as the grandma pizza and various specialty pizzas, reflect the rich culinary heritage of Italy, while also embracing the local palate.

The atmosphere at Johnny's is as inviting as the food.

Families often gather here, sharing stories over slices after a long day. The friendly staff enhances the experience, ensuring that each guest feels valued. The charm of Johnny's Pizzeria goes beyond its food; it’s a space where community thrives, and memories are made. Patrons often linger to enjoy the ambiance, especially during sunset when the warm glow fills the dining area.

With about 55 exceptional dishes on the menu, Johnny's is not just a pizza place; it serves up comfort and creativity in every offering.

The selection ranges from classic pizzas by the slice, like the Fresh Mozzarella and Veggie Pizza, to indulgent calzones like the Chicken Parmigiana Roll. This variety makes it a perfect destination for both quick bites and leisurely meals. The average cost, about $6.75 per item, makes it accessible, catering to a wide audience.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayOpen
  • MondayOpen
  • TuesdayOpen
  • WednesdayOpen
  • ThursdayOpen
  • FridayOpen
  • SaturdayOpen

Johnny's Pizzeria boasts a wide variety of pizza specialties, including square, white, and inventive combinations that showcase the culinary creativity of the kitchen staff. From the comforting Lasagna Pizza to the tropical flair of Natalie's Hawaiian Pizza, the menu offers something for everyone. The pizzeria doesn't stop at just pizza; it features calzones, rolls, and delectable pasta dishes. With 55 items on the menu and prices averaging around $6.75, diners find both value and quality in every meal. Alongside the food, a selection of beverages rounds out the dining experience, making it easy to quench thirst while enjoying a fantastic meal.

Johnny's Pizzeria

The exterior of Johnny's Pizzeria captures the essence of Brooklyn with its casual, inviting vibe. A bright sign overhead beckons passersby to stop in for a delicious meal. The outdoor seating allows patrons to enjoy their food al fresco, making it a fantastic option on warm days. Lively chatter often spills out onto the street, creating a friendly neighborhood atmosphere that draws in curious diners. The pizzeria is a hub for social interaction, with friends and families gathering around tables, sharing pizzas during sunset, adding to its community-focused identity.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Johnny's has all the makings of greatness: old-school digs, counter serve, locals of all stripes. And the pizza is excellent. Soft fresh dough, quality moz, bright sauce. Not sure Italians run it anymore, but who cares. Top 10 Brooklyn slice joints?

R
Rob K.

If you find yourself in Sunset Park, Brooklyn, pop into Johnny's Pizza for the real deal. The owner, Johnny, took my son's multiple allergies (pn, tn, egg, fish, sesame, poppy, pumpkin, sunflower seeds) very seriously; in fact, Johnny's daughter has allergies, so he understood! Johnny's is very much an old-school, authentic pizza joint-nothing fancy- just really delicious Brooklyn pizza! Perfection!! Pictured is their square pie.

K
Kate R.

This is a classic pizzeria that has withstood the test of time. Est. 1968 the pizza is delicious the variety is enough to keep traditionalists like myself happy with extra cheese and pepperoni and sausage or the grandma slice and for the more adventurous types they will be pleased by the Hawaiian style. They also have appetizers like beef patties, garlic knots and they make delicious heros and pasta dishes. Take a trip to this great place and Manga!! Enjoy!!!

M
Miz P.

Best potato croquettes in town. Sad to see this place shut down

H
Harsh

End of an era. I had two pepperoni and a grandma, phenomenal.

T
The M.

Best pizza in Brooklyn, arguably best in NYC. Prove me wrong via taste test, but you're buying.

M
Michael N.